Free Will - Libertarian / Conservative News, Politics, and Economics Blog

Free Will Classic

2:33 am, 12/5/03

When was Eden?
Michael Crichton completely nails it.

Today, one of the most powerful religions in the Western World is environmentalism. Environmentalism seems to be the religion of choice for urban atheists. Why do I say it's a religion? Well, just look at the beliefs. If you look carefully, you see that environmentalism is in fact a perfect 21st century remapping of traditional Judeo-Christian beliefs and myths.

There's an initial Eden, a paradise, a state of grace and unity with nature, there's a fall from grace into a state of pollution as a result of eating from the tree of knowledge, and as a result of our actions there is a judgment day coming for us all. We are all energy sinners, doomed to die, unless we seek salvation, which is now called sustainability. Sustainability is salvation in the church of the environment. Just as organic food is its communion, that pesticide-free wafer that the right people with the right beliefs, imbibe.

There is no Eden. There never was. What was that Eden of the wonderful mythic past? Is it the time when infant mortality was 80%, when four children in five died of disease before the age of five? When one woman in six died in childbirth? When the average lifespan was 40, as it was in America a century ago. When plagues swept across the planet, killing millions in a stroke. Was it when millions starved to death? Is that when it was Eden?

And what about indigenous peoples, living in a state of harmony with the Eden-like environment? Well, they never did. On this continent, the newly arrived people who crossed the land bridge almost immediately set about wiping out hundreds of species of large animals, and they did this several thousand years before the white man showed up, to accelerate the process. And what was the condition of life? Loving, peaceful, harmonious? Hardly: the early peoples of the New World lived in a state of constant warfare. Generations of hatred, tribal hatreds, constant battles. The warlike tribes of this continent are famous: the Comanche, Sioux, Apache, Mohawk, Aztecs, Toltec, Incas. Some of them practiced infanticide, and human sacrifice. And those tribes that were not fiercely warlike were exterminated, or learned to build their villages high in the cliffs to attain some measure of safety.

How about the human condition in the rest of the world? The Maori of New Zealand committed massacres regularly. The dyaks of Borneo were headhunters. The Polynesians, living in an environment as close to paradise as one can imagine, fought constantly, and created a society so hideously restrictive that you could lose your life if you stepped in the footprint of a chief. It was the Polynesians who gave us the very concept of taboo, as well as the word itself. The noble savage is a fantasy, and it was never true. That anyone still believes it, 200 years after Rousseau, shows the tenacity of religious myths, their ability to hang on in the face of centuries of factual contradiction.

In short, the romantic view of the natural world as a blissful Eden is only held by people who have no actual experience of nature. People who live in nature are not romantic about it at all. They may hold spiritual beliefs about the world around them, they may have a sense of the unity of nature or the aliveness of all things, but they still kill the animals and uproot the plants in order to eat, to live. If they don't, they will die.

The truth is, almost nobody wants to experience real nature. What people want is to spend a week or two in a cabin in the woods, with screens on the windows. They want a simplified life for a while, without all their stuff. Or a nice river rafting trip for a few days, with somebody else doing the cooking. Nobody wants to go back to nature in any real way, and nobody does. It's all talk-and as the years go on, and the world population grows increasingly urban, it's uninformed talk. Farmers know what they're talking about. City people don't. It's all fantasy.

But let's return to religion. If Eden is a fantasy that never existed, and mankind wasn't ever noble and kind and loving, if we didn't fall from grace, then what about the rest of the religious tenets? What about salvation, sustainability, and judgment day? What about the coming environmental doom from fossil fuels and global warming, if we all don't get down on our knees and conserve every day?

...Nobody anywhere will say that the core fears expressed for most of my life have turned out not to be true. As we have moved into the future, these doomsday visions vanished, like a mirage in the desert. They were never there---though they still appear, in the future. As mirages do.

Okay, so, the preachers made a mistake. They got one prediction wrong; they're human. So what. Unfortunately, it's not just one prediction. It's a whole slew of them. We are running out of oil. We are running out of all natural resources. Paul Ehrlich: 60 million Americans will die of starvation in the 1980s. Forty thousand species become extinct every year. Half of all species on the planet will be extinct by 2000. And on and on and on.

With so many past failures, you might think that environmental predictions would become more cautious. But not if it's a religion. Remember, the nut on the sidewalk carrying the placard that predicts the end of the world doesn't quit when the world doesn't end on the day he expects. He just changes his placard, sets a new doomsday date, and goes back to walking the streets.

Read the whole damn thing. It's full of more sweet goodies than a Christmas stocking. (Via Kallini.com)

Free Will Classic
Comment (4)

money at 12:55 AM, 10/9/06

In Oklahoma tissues are not to be found in the back of one's car <a href= "http://mbankrupter.blogspot.com/" >Restrictive Covenants</a> and <a href= "http://www.live.com/" >money </a> <a href= "http://www.burchie.com/blog/2006_05_01_burchie_archive.html" >Condominium Conversion</a> <a href= "http://www.joeymrobinson.com/guest.html" >Foreclosure</a> <a href= "http://www.bitsofnews.com/index.php?subaction=showcomments&id=1107300506&archive=&start_from=&ucat=&" >Specific Performance</a>

money at 01:01 PM, 10/20/06

Zero percent is the ultimate in great deals and zero-percent cards are great for consolidating debt by transferring balances from other cards into one. <a href= "http://negloaner.blogspot.com/" >Settlement Premium</a> and <a href= "http://www.live.com/" >money </a> <a href= "http://files.drakan.ru/cgi-bin/doska/2rtAwb/getdoska.cgi?topic_id=7&from=901" >Firm Commitment</a> <a href= "http://wedding.perfectdaygift.net/wedding_photo_book/guest.htm" >Survey</a> <a href= "http://www.radio-saigon.com/WP/archives/2005/08/15/too-much-talking-not-enough-understanding" >Buy down</a>

money at 04:29 AM, 10/27/06

Growing evidence that the economy is slowing is behind the decline in interest rates, which move in the opposite direction from bond prices. <a href= "http://oldweb.uwp.edu/academic/business/news/articles/credit-cards-debt.html" >credit cards debt</a> and <a href= "http://www.live.com/" >money </a> <a href= "http://project9.jp/mimic286.0/mimic2.cgi?page=5" >Real Property</a> <a href= "http://www.forumimpastato.org/content/visualizza_messaggi.asp?dir=next&pag=17" >Fully Amortized ARM</a> <a href= "http://www.unit-net.co.jp/cgi-local/yybbs2/yybbs.cgi?page=46" >Rate Lock</a>

money at 02:51 PM, 12/12/06

If paying your mortgage has become a hardship, it's time to look for a better deal. <a href= "http://hr.nau.edu/docs/man/New-Jersey-Mortgage-Rates.html" >new jersey mortgage rates</a> and <a href= "http://www.live.com/" >money </a>

Comment Policy: Irrelevant or obscene posts, including ad hominem attacks, SPAM, crazed ranting, and threats of violence may be removed at the owner of this site's discretion.